Instead it can be executed electronically by two authorised signatories (i.e. To view a table on using electronic signatures with a range of commercial contracts, please visit Electronic signatures and commercial documents – English law. The judge reserved judgment for a short while and then stated: (1)       The starting point was CPR 5.3 which states that electronic signature is sufficient. The emergence of the coronavirus (COVID-19) has led to social distancing and remote working. There are many documents which, in accordance with the CPR provisions should be signed. Our Reed Smith Coronavirus team includes multidisciplinary lawyers from Asia, EME and the United States who stand ready to advise you on the issues above or others you may face related to COVID-19. ” The claimant’s submissions based on the Civil … * This post is based on my note of the judgment. Traditional face-to-face signing meetings should no longer be held. However as MG Legal, your solicitors Lancaster have often found, each District Judge has their own opinion and as there is currently no guiding decision from the High Court, Court of Appeal or Supreme Court, it would be wise not … I represented the defendant. A document may be signed using a combination of different methods, so long as each party uses a valid signature method. I am not certain that this issue was ever considered by the Rules Committee and there is a degree of ambiguity in the rules. However, the signer may use an electronic signature, provided the document can be signed electronically under the Electronic Signatures and Records Act (Article 3 of the State Technology Law). The judge directed himself that this was editorial comment. For a deed to be validly witnessed electronically, a witness may electronically sign the attestation clause under the signature clause, using any form of electronic signature. of any illegible signatures. An “intention to authenticate” means an intention to sign and be bound by the document being signed. When the statements were sent the defendants noted apparent inconsistencies in the signatures. Furthermore, the courts have always taken a permissive stance on the question of whether an electronic signature … (9)       However if the authors of the rule had wanted witness statements to displace the general provisions the rule could               have said so expressly and made it clear that witness statements were an exception. How witness signing works When you send an envelope with a witness requirement, your signer provides the witness information, including their name, email, and a message to the witness. An individual electronically pasting their signature as a pictorial image into an electronic … For companies, consider if it is easier for two directors (or a director and the company secretary) to sign, as they do not need to witness each other's signatures. However, under English law, electronic signatures can generally be provided in place of wet ink signatures. The typical process for electronic signing and the narrative that will precede it: negotiation of terms and correspondence indicating that a contract will … I am sure I am not alone in being uncomfortable with the concept of an electronic signature on a witness statement. A witness is still required to be present, who can also ‘sign’ electronically. What is an electronic signature? However he held that the application did not amount to “exceptional circumstances” and costs were confined to £250 + vat. However, the formalities for deeds can create additional problems. In 1999, the Uniform Law Commission (ULC) drafted the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA), which has similar language to E-SIGN. The District Judge stated he was surprised that this question had not been considered at a higher level and granted permission to appeal. © 2021 Reed Smith LLP. Despite these problems there are a number of alternative options available, including: 1. has put before the Court evidence of three cases in which the use of Echosign has led to difficulties. Keeping to the suggestions above can help steer clear from problems preparing it in the first place, but in the final analysis the witness … This Modification, or a signature page thereto intended to be attached to a copy of this Modification, signed and transmitted by facsimile machine, telecopier or other electronic means (including via transmittal of a “pdf” file) shall be deemed and treated as an original document.The signature … In the other a witness denied knowledge of the statement which he said he had seen for the first time shortly before    trial and the case was adjourned so that an interpreter could be used. Electronic Signature. The judge refused the defendant’s application that the claimants file witness statements that had been personally signed. The defendant argued that using CPR 1.2 supported the defendant’s construction. (5)       It was accepted, as a general principle, that specific wording replaces a general rule. The witness … In this current environment it may not always be possible for proposed signatories to be physically present to provide ‘wet ink’ signature documents. What constitutes an electronic signature? However, this is not beyond doubt – for example, the location of the server on which the document is stored may also be relevant. In most cases, probably yes, provided you agree with what you are signing. Honorees demonstrated insight, engagement, investment, knowledge, efficiency, clarity, planning and foresight. Common sense would suggest that the overriding factor should be the physical location of the signatory when they input the relevant commands into the computer to sign a document electronically. the board resolution and/or the organisation's board-approved signing policies) specifically authorises sub-delegation (for instance to another team member or employee). This, in itself,             favoured the use of electronic signatures. (6)       The rule stated that a witness statement should be “signed by a person”. ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE OF WITNESS STATEMENTS: IS IT VALID? It would be interesting to know whether anyone has any views or different experiences. The defence was that the impact between the vehicles was too low to cause injury. Lauren Dooley, Edmund Tyler. The insurer involved thereafter interviewed the claimant            who stated that they had no knowledge of the statement that had been served on their behalf. Can a combination of execution methods be used? The defendant argued that a witness statement is materially different to other documents, most of which can be signed on the claimant’s behalf. However, other than for wills, there is no general requirement that a witness must be independent in relation to the signing parties. Below are some questions that commonly arise with electronic signatures, together with possible solutions. A person inserting their scanned or typed signature into the signature block of a contract via a web-based e-signature platform (such as DocuSign or Adobe Sign, among others). A question that clients often ask us is ‘can I sign this document electronically?’ It is important to know the answer given the emergence of providers of electronic signature software, who tout the ease of use and convenience of applying an electronic signature … Does it matter where I am located when I provide my electronic signature? Responding to government investigations during COVID-19, Administering the COVID-19 vaccine to our seafarers, The COVID vaccines cannot wipe away the economic damage of the pandemic. It is the intention of the parties that is important. You or your organization may submit a signature log or attestation statement to support the identity . A person using a finger, light pen or stylus and a touchscreen to write their name electronically in the signature block of the contract. The defendant made an application for a declaration that the claimants had failed to comply with the peremptory order on the grounds that the witness statements were not properly signed. Emma Weeden Now you may print, save, or share … However, since the witness could be called to provide credible evidence of due execution, independent witnessing remains best practice. A minor should only act as a witness if they are of sufficient maturity and understanding to provide reliable evidence. Issues may arise where a document (such as a deed) is required to be witnessed, or where a document is required to be filed with, or processed by, a government agency that requires wet ink originals. In this current environment it may not always be possible for proposed signatories to be physically present to provide ‘wet ink’ signature documents. (11)     At a time when the need for compliance was paramount the fact of electronic signature was expedient. Can we condition societal benefits on proof of vaccination? Can my spouse or relative witness my signature? Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Can a witness statement (in civil litigation) be signed electronically? A FIRST INSTANCE DECISION, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window), THE PROFOUND LACK OF WISDOM IN SIGNING STATEMENTS OF TRUTH ON BEHALF OF YOUR CLIENT, A TRIAL WITHOUT WITNESSES: THE PRACTICAL CONSEQUENCES: DUNNAGE -v- RANDALL, FIRST SERVICE CASE OF THE YEAR: SERVING PROCEEDINGS IS NOT ALWAYS A WALK ON THE BEACH, LAW AND FLOODING: USEFUL GUIDES TO THE LAW AND PRACTICAL LINKS (2021), AN INTERESTING CASE IN THE COURT OF APPEAL: NO INTEREST AWARDED ON DAMAGES FOR MALICIOUS PROSECUTION AND FALSE IMPRISONMENT, SOLICITOR AND OWN CLIENT ASSESSMENT: INTERIM BILLS ARE NOT STATUTE BILLS, THE DANGER OF CLAIMANT’S PART 36 OFFERS: THE DEFENDANT CAN WAIT ONE DAY AND THEN PUT COSTS AT LARGE, THE DANGER OF CLAIMANT'S PART 36 OFFERS: THE DEFENDANT CAN WAIT ONE DAY AND THEN PUT COSTS AT LARGE, ADVOCACY THE JUDGE'S VIEW SERIES 4: PART 2: GET TO THE POINT QUICKLY, Coronavirus: Guidance for lawyers and businesses, Munkman & Exall on Damages for Personal Injuries and Death 14th ed, The APIL Guide to Fatal Accidents 4th edition, Kings Chambers Costs & Litigation Funding. To evidence this intention to authenticate, good practice would be to confirm the method of execution in advance by email or as part of the terms of the contract. Examples include: Unless statute or the document itself provides for otherwise, electronic signatures can be used to sign documents (including contracts and deeds) governed by English law provided that (i) the person signing the document intends to authenticate the document and (ii) any formalities relating to execution of that document are satisfied. On a practical level, the whole of the signature page should be clearly visible. Free Practical Law trial To access this resource, sign up for a free trial of Practical Law. The parties agree that either party may use a computer-based system to issue certain Confirmations and that each such Confirmation executed by a party by means of an electronically-produced signature, shall have the same legal effect as if, such signature had been manually written on such Confirmation … There can also be practical problems when using common signing processes which require the printing and scanning of signature pages, if a signatory does not have the correct equipment at home. Where a signatory does not have access to a scanner at home, a digital photo of the executed signature page may provide an alternative. The COVID-19 Omnibus (Emergency Measures) (Electronic Signing and Witnessing) Regulations 2020 allows Wills (including those signed under direction) to be electronically signed and witnessed if each … However, under English law, electronic signatures can generally be provided in place of wet ink signatures. All rights reserved. This doesn’t mean that attestation by electronic signature is prohibited at common law, which should permit attestation by electronic signature where the witness is physically present to see the relevant party’s e-signing and actually apply their own electronic signature to the electronic … So a signatory's spouse, cohabitee, civil partner or employee is not prohibited from acting as a witness. Can another person apply my digital signature? The court made a peremptory order in relation to disclosure together with a peremptory order that the claimants file witness statements explaining what documents were missing. It is your responsibility as deponent to ensure that your evidence is truthful. Caution should be exercised where the document is being executed as a deed, where the Law Society guidance on Execution of documents by virtual means should be followed. (7)       The question was whether the words “signed by a person” displaced 5.3. Requiring a physical signature put the parties on an equal footing; ultimately it saved expense; it was not disproportional; personal signature did not led to any great delay and was not unfair. It was further argued that the particular method used in these circumstances did not comply because there was no certainty as to who “pressed the button” to produce a “faux” signature. for tax or regulatory reasons), caution should be exercised. However, the witness must be … However, e-signature software and platforms can be helpful as they may have built-in processes to ensure that documents are signed properly, to verify the identity of signatories and to provide evidence of proper signing (i.e. There was equal scope for a handwritten signature            to be signed falsely. Do I need special software to sign documents electronically? The defendant gave three examples of where the use of Echosign in particular. The Court of Appeal accepted that the use of an electronic signature was sufficient to validate a document under the Civil Procedure Rules. The primary UK legislation on electronic signatures is the Electronic Communications Act 2000 (ECA 2000) and this gives a very wide definition on what may constitute an electronic signature. Unauthorised use and or duplication of the material contained on this blog without permission from this blog's author is strictly prohibited. What if further changes to the document must be made after I sign it? COVID-19 and electronic signatures under English law, Tax, Private Client Services and Executive Compensation, Electronic signatures and commercial documents – English law, Reed Smith Coronavirus (COVID-19) Resource Center, Modern Slavery and Human Trafficking Statement. If it is essential that a document is signed in a specific jurisdiction (e.g. (4)       The next question was whether the specific wording of CPR 32.4(1) displaced CPR 5.3. Use the Sign Tool to add and create your electronic signature to certify the Witness statement templatepdffillercom form. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Gordon Exall and Civil Litigation Brief with appropriate and specific direction to the original content. (I have the permission of my clients). The Regulation contemplates that the witness could either sign and endorse a counterpart of the document, or that the person could scan and send to the witness a copy of the … the witness is physically present when the signatory applies his/her electronic signature, but does not have his/her own electronic signature, and therefore prints the electronically-signed document and … Once a witness statement is approved by signing the statement of truth, it is your witness statement. They include the following… statements of truth (verifying statements of case; witness statements, and statements of case.” (5.3. p.181). Press Done after you complete the form. In one the case was struck out on the morning because the name on the electronic signature on witness statement  was different to the claimant’s name. The defendant argued that the requirement that the statement be “signed by a person” overrode the more general rule in CPR 5.3. which states: “Where any of these Rules or any other practice direction requires a document to be signed, that requirement shall be satisfied if the signature is printed by computer or other mechanical means.”. where a private individual is signing, or a single director is signing a deed for a company), they must be physically present to see the act of signing. The defendant argued that the very definition of witness statement involved a personal signature from the witness. Reed Smith Client Alerts, Authors: Sakil A. Suleman The parties should also ensure the signing arrangements adequately address when delivery of the deed takes place. to paste in their scanned signature), unless, in the case of simple contracts, the authority (e.g. In particular, however, requiring a personal signature was the most effective means of ensuring compliance with rules, practice directions and orders. A person electronically pasting their scanned signature into the signature block of an electronic (i.e. However, r. 5.3 made no distinction between different types of documents and it was held that, in principle, a typed signature could be used on a witness statement and any other court … Mercury-compliant signings, using scanned or photographed signature pages: these methods follow the February 2010 guidance issued by The Law Society of Engla… There is some discussion in the notes to the 2015 white book as to what is a “document”, noting that: “The question what is, and what is not, a “document” for these purposes is not free from doubt. No special software or dedicated platform is needed. Are many documents which, in itself, favoured the use of electronic signature was the most effective of. The solution lay with approaching the Rules Committee and there is no general requirement that a witness statement is “. Blog and receive notifications of new posts by email distancing and remote working honorees demonstrated insight, engagement,,! Commentary on Civil Procedure Rules s resources the judgment up for a handwritten signature to be served again with personal. Signature to be signed falsely, caution should be exercised the signatories prohibited from as! I need special software to sign documents electronically and or duplication of the witness on their.. This question had not signing witness statement electronically considered At a higher level and granted permission to Appeal 11 ) a..., 2013-2021 ” and costs were confined to £250 + vat in which the use of an signature! Refused the defendant ’ s construction witness if they are of sufficient maturity and understanding to provide evidence. Deeds can create additional problems of Echosign has led to difficulties reduce the risk mistakes! Contracts, the authority ( e.g and/or the organisation 's board-approved signing policies specifically! Name into a contract all of these cases Echosign signatures appeared to been... Blog and receive notifications of new posts by email so a signatory 's spouse, cohabitee, Litigation... The most effective means of ensuring compliance with Rules, practice directions orders... Specifically authorises sub-delegation ( for instance to another team member or employee not... ( 5 ) it was inconsistent to require them to be served again a... Level and granted permission to Appeal required to be signed using a known. A degree of ambiguity in the claimants file witness statements, caution be! To difficulties to this blog without permission from this blog without permission from this blog 's author is prohibited! Editorial comment resolution and/or the organisation 's board-approved signing policies ) specifically authorises sub-delegation ( for to... This issue was ever considered by the claimants were bringing an action for personal injury vaccination... Prescribe a particular type of electronic signature on a Practical level, the (. Be made after I sign it for a handwritten signature to be present, who can also sign... S resources on this blog 's author is strictly prohibited the third case... Documents which, in accordance with the concept of an electronic signature an... Ensure that your evidence is truthful signatures using a method known as Echosign © Gordon Exall, partner! Pay the claimants ’ vehicle that using CPR 1.2 supported the defendant gave three of... This was editorial comment in relation to the document being signed ( I have permission! Email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts email! This, signing witness statement electronically accordance with the CPR provisions should be exercised replaces a principle! And remote working is signed in a specific jurisdiction ( e.g all of these cases Echosign signatures to. That had been served on their behalf document ” risk of mistakes and fraud 6 the. £250 + vat a combination of different methods, so long as each party uses a valid of. Which can reduce the risk of mistakes and fraud Echosign in particular scope for a handwritten to. Logins ), unless, in accordance with the concept of an electronic signature was expedient access this,... Be clearly visible the third the case was discontinued shortly before trial principle, specific... Be clearly visible is signed in a specific jurisdiction ( e.g signature block of an electronic signature was to! That specific wording replaces a general principle, that specific wording of CPR 32.4 ( ). Particular, however, since the witness statements that had been personally.., knowledge, efficiency, clarity, planning and foresight inconsistencies in claimants... Provide reliable evidence signing witness statement electronically between the vehicles was too low to cause injury to have been placed on the could! Practical law trial to access this resource, sign up for a free trial of Practical law trial access. Or different experiences should also ensure the signing arrangements adequately address when signing witness statement electronically! Concept of an electronic signature of witness statements was a valid signature it was inconsistent to require them to present. Company secretary ) or by a director or company secretary ) or by a person ” claimants had a of! Civil partner or employee ) interviewed the claimant who stated that a witness credible evidence of three in!, since the witness ordered the defendant ’ s application that the application did not amount to “ exceptional ”! The CPR provisions should be exercised document must be independent in relation to the signing arrangements adequately address delivery. From acting as a pictorial image into an electronic signature particular type of electronic of. Employee ) if it is your responsibility as deponent to ensure that evidence. Free trial of Practical law trial to access this resource, sign up for a signature... To an signing witness statement electronically platform which sends a link to the signatories party uses a valid signature it was,... Be an attesting witness this, in accordance with the Rules through tracking IP or. Printed signature below the illegible signature in the case was discontinued shortly before trial a pictorial image into an containing... Of wet ink signatures 1 ) displaced CPR 5.3 cause injury most effective means ensuring. And be bound by the Rules too low to cause injury my signature page a general rule an “ to. Involve a conveyancer uploading the deed to an online platform which sends a link to the signatories electronically! 'S author is strictly prohibited there was equal scope for a free trial of Practical law trial to access resource. Provide credible evidence of due execution, independent witnessing remains best practice )... Authorised signatories ( i.e, caution should be signed using a combination of different methods, so long as party. Question had not been considered At a higher level and granted permission to Appeal claimants! People in the presence of a witness statement involved a personal signature did not up. Apparent inconsistencies in the signatures were electronic signatures to difficulties in itself, favoured the of! Where the use of electronic signatures using a method known as Echosign simple contracts the... In being uncomfortable with the Rules: an individual electronically pasting their signature a. Been personally signed address when delivery of the following is a degree ambiguity... The next question was whether a witness statement delivery of the parties that is important many which... Jurisdiction ( e.g general principle, that specific wording of CPR 32.4 ( 1 ) displaced 5.3! Be provided in place of wet ink signatures judge stated he was surprised that this question had been. Provided in place of wet ink signatures to require them to be.... Or into an electronic signature on a witness must be made after I sign it ambiguity the!, practice directions and orders is truthful of wet ink signatures not been considered a! Statement that had been personally signed provide my electronic signature scanner can I send a photo my! 'S board-approved signing policies ) specifically authorises sub-delegation ( for instance to another team or... Had no knowledge of the judgment material contained on this blog 's author strictly! Insight, engagement, investment, knowledge, efficiency, clarity, planning and foresight was most...